To Frog or Not to Frog

I am about 7 inches in on Sue's shawl.  Here's the problem, though.  While I LOVE it... I'm thinking it won't be wide enough.  This particular shawl is a wrap type shaw and therefore, is basically nothing more than a large scarf.  Its about 22 inches wide and 65 inches long when complete.  Very large scarf. 

I just think Sue would rather have  triangular shawl like the one I made Peggy.  Soooo... today I am considering frogging it and choosing another pattern.  I will have to ponder this for a while and obssesively look at patterns some more. 

O.k. here's the pic:

So anyway... I'll let you know tomorrow what I decide to do.  Today is my doctor's appointment, so I may not get to worry about it until tonight after bedtime.